• Jasmine: Masterclass at the Vaudeville Theatre: wonderful play, Tyne Daley is fabulous!! You must get a ticket asap http://t.co/0bYt9t0T (9th Feb 2012 - 23:11)
  • Jasmine: RT @Moneymagpie: Is pampering a waste of time and money?... http://t.co/ed9x4am7 <<Yes! (first time I've agreed with Burchill!) (9th Feb 2012 - 23:10)
  • Jasmine: @zoerobinson1 Ooh well done! (9th Feb 2012 - 23:09)
  • Moneymagpie: Is pampering a waste of time and money?: She’s probably one of the UK’s most controversial columnists and now Ju... http://t.co/ng22TMxL (9th Feb 2012 - 14:00)
  • Moneymagpie: Moneymagpie has come up with 50 ways you can save money at home without making drastic changes to your life. Use... http://t.co/qZ4XX0nQ (9th Feb 2012 - 10:42)
  • Moneymagpie: @concordextra Glad we can help! (9th Feb 2012 - 10:34)
  • Moneymagpie: Sign up to http://t.co/Lw3lOEJD and you can leave feedback on the best and worst places to shop. Find out about... http://t.co/TLXSQxFu (9th Feb 2012 - 10:07)
  • Moneymagpie: Online exclusive! Get 10% off all online orders at Superdrug until Valentine's Day only:... http://t.co/PDssmTM5 (9th Feb 2012 - 09:19)
  • Moneymagpie: Get this - cheap and cheerful, energy-saving wind-up torches!... http://t.co/IVA5ZQkR (8th Feb 2012 - 22:19)
  • Jasmine: @Brandamplifier Hey, I can't remember if I sent over this piece about the birth of PR. If not, here it is! http://t.co/00XpXX3l (8th Feb 2012 - 22:15)
  • Moneymagpie: Illuminations To Go: The advent of low-cost LEDs in torches has brought about something of a revolution in porta... http://t.co/0epWMyC8 (8th Feb 2012 - 18:01)
  • Jasmine: @Poorlybee Nice! Spooky thing, tho, your tweet has also been sent by someone called Ellen (8th Feb 2012 - 16:43)
  • Jasmine: @Poorlybee No...it was oh...sorry...must stop going thro that mail (although honestly, I didn't know which you meant...trying to look clever (8th Feb 2012 - 16:33)
  • Jasmine: @Poorlybee Oh (8th Feb 2012 - 16:23)
  • Jasmine: Another nasty spam bot. This time says "@x We want to Hire YOU to Tweet at [dodgy virus-filled link]". Watch out. (8th Feb 2012 - 16:23)
  • Jasmine: Good for Russell Brand if he isn't taking money from Perry's estate. Respect. Like Billie Piper with Chris Evans. Quite right. (8th Feb 2012 - 16:21)
  • Moneymagpie: Premier Inn are celebrating the leap year by releasing 29,000 rooms from £29 for stays between 29th February and... http://t.co/R8jGtk4f (8th Feb 2012 - 16:10)
  • Moneymagpie: @oddbohemian Yes, very good point. Tell other people, don't do it myself! (8th Feb 2012 - 15:49)
  • Moneymagpie: @oddbohemian very practical! (8th Feb 2012 - 15:48)
  • Moneymagpie: Valentine’s flowers: where to find the best bouquets: Flowers make up almost two thirds of all Valentine spendin... http://t.co/2U93D3z9 (8th Feb 2012 - 15:47)
  • Moneymagpie: The cupcake challenge! With only 3 of us in the office, can we eat all 9 (!) of this box of cupcakes given to us... http://t.co/S24jKrnR (8th Feb 2012 - 15:26)
  • Jasmine: @michaelbeddoes nice! (8th Feb 2012 - 15:14)
  • Jasmine: RT @michaelbeddoes: If @pauljchambers isn't cleared,a peaceful protest should happen with people showing their usernames and a joke (8th Feb 2012 - 15:12)
  • Jasmine: RT @ajhmurray: If this goes against Paul I suggest that all of us put in our bio my tweets may well be jokes. Seriously. #twitterjoketrial (8th Feb 2012 - 15:00)
  • Jasmine: Ah Romance. So far today I've had Valentine's press releases about debt, divorce, credit ratings and how to be a low-cost lover. *sigh* (8th Feb 2012 - 14:59)
  • Moneymagpie: I used a nice thick scarf to block drafts from my big window today. Time to take a leaf out of our own article on... http://t.co/xBccpM4T (8th Feb 2012 - 14:35)
  • Moneymagpie: Looking for advice on ways to pay off debt? Moneymagpie has seven simple debt solutions which can help you to be... http://t.co/Zgn11p41 (8th Feb 2012 - 14:08)
  • Jasmine: The Euro is extraordinary. Now at 8-week high v the dollar a/c HIFX (8th Feb 2012 - 10:42)
  • Moneymagpie: Don't forget to make the most of Moneymagpie's special 10% discount at eFlorist. Whether you're after a... http://t.co/QZAUmQ1H (8th Feb 2012 - 10:22)
  • Moneymagpie: With Valentine's day fast approaching take a look at Bloomin' Delightful's stunning bouquets starting at just... http://t.co/vODdCbIP (8th Feb 2012 - 10:17)
  • Moneymagpie: If you're looking to book a hotel room Travelodge have some great rates starting from just £19 per room and if... http://t.co/MJZBcqzY (8th Feb 2012 - 10:12)
  • Jasmine: If women have implants for looks then they should pay to have them taken out. not the same as necessary surgery #newsnight (7th Feb 2012 - 22:56)
  • Jasmine: RT @stewartfoster: #newsnight is resembling an ad for Foxy Bingo tonight. << true (7th Feb 2012 - 22:53)
  • Jasmine: @EvanHD true! (7th Feb 2012 - 22:49)
  • Jasmine: @Nico_Macdonald Good point made at the debate this evening. Totally agree about growth coming from production. Needs more encouragement. (7th Feb 2012 - 21:49)
  • Jasmine: RT @martin_greig: Man from the Pru is (sort of) coming back 10yrs after 1,600 got chop http://t.co/iuJYlmVB <<hope they don't sell rubbish (7th Feb 2012 - 21:44)
  • Jasmine: Very, very good debate at Royal Geog Soc this evening "What hope for the economy?". John Kay marvellous. @EvanHD v gd moderator (7th Feb 2012 - 21:30)
  • Moneymagpie: Back at my brother's house, Norman the cat and Harvey the dog are having a nap http://t.co/oGeTICmv (7th Feb 2012 - 18:11)
  • Moneymagpie: RT @tescohome: @moneymagpie You forgot to mention us! We do free #insulation and offer 5,000 clubcard points to those on benefits! <<sorry! (7th Feb 2012 - 16:57)
  • Moneymagpie: The Moneymagpie newsletter is out. Great Love Film offer x http://t.co/LwWJrqGo http://t.co/kQLV81hW (7th Feb 2012 - 14:38)

Saving: cash ISAs – how to choose the best

Alexander Ridler/Flickr

Updated: 4/1/2012

Everyone should be making the most of tax-free savings so find out everything you need to know, plus all the latest best buys with our comprehensive guide.

Banks are desperate to grab your custom before the 6 April ISA deadline hits – and so are trying to out-do each other by offering higher interest rates. This is good news for the man on the street – so read on to find out how to make the most of your ISA opportunity!

the moneymagpie isa comparison tool

What is a cash ISA?

A cash ISA (Individual Savings Account) is essentially a tax-free savings account available to any UK resident aged 16 or over.

An ISA isn’t an investment in itself. It’s just a ‘wrapper’ that protects your savings from tax. Putting money in a cash Isa is just the same as putting money in a building society account or online savings account, but you’re wrapping it in a tax-free savings ‘bag’, so when you get your interest on the money you don’t lose any of it in nasty tax payments.

How much can I invest?

You can now put up to £5,340 into cash ISA each financial year – that’s 6 April 2011 to 5 April 2012. You can also put up to £5,340 in a stocks and shares ISA in the same tax year. If you’d like to put it all in stocks and shares, though, you can do that up to a limit of £10,680 in the tax year.

How does it work?

Once you put the money in you can take it out again, but you may not be able to put it all back into your ISA in the same tax year. This is because you can only put in money up to the savings limit for that type of ISA in any tax year. This rule applies whether the amount paid in is new saving or replacing amounts withdrawn earlier.

Once the money is in the ISA, however, you can transfer it directly into another ISA with another company, as long as that company lets you and you don’t exceed your annual allowance.

You’ll find that most banks will be letting the over-50s top-up their current ISAs with their additional allowance, but double check with your bank or building society.

Are all Cash ISAs the same?

No. Exactly like savings accounts you can get different types of cash ISA – easy access, fixed rate and notice accounts. And, in the same way as normal savings accounts, different types of cash ISA suit different people.

Easy Access ISAs – these are ISAs which won’t penalise you to withdraw your money should you need to. For this luxury though you’ll have to sacrifice the very best rates.

Fixed Rate ISAs – these are ISAs which guarantee the amount of interest you’ll receive for a fixed period of time. Generally the longer the term, the more interest you’ll receive. Remember though that with these ISAs you’ll be penalised for early withdrawals, and if you tie your money up for too long you might miss out if interest rates rise in the near future.

Notice ISAs - these are generally available as postal accounts and will allow you to withdraw money if you give a set amount of notice before you wish to do so.

Remember that you can transfer your cash between ISAs (as long as the new ISA you choose allows this). So, keep a close eye on the cash ISA best buy tables and transfer your money as and when you like to take advantage of the top rates. Just remember that some ISA providers may penalise you for withdrawing your cash early.

So, should you have one?

As with most things financial, it depends on your personal circumstances.

These are the reasons why you might not want to get a cash ISA this financial year:

You might want to put your full allowance into a shares ISA

This financial year (until 5 April 2012) you can put up to £10,680 altogether in ISA-wrapped investments either in two ISAs – £5,340 each in a cash ISA and a shares ISA or in one big shares ISA.

In the long term, investments in shares will give usually give you a bigger return. By ‘long term’ we mean at least five years. So if you’re planning to use your ISA allowance to invest for your future, we suggest you put that money into shares.

You might be planning to use that extra money to pay off all or part of your mortgage

This is a great idea, too. Paying off chunks of your mortgage means that you’ll be mortgage-free in much less time. You will save loads of money (like tens of thousands of pounds) in interest payments and your gains will be tax free.

When you pay money into your mortgage and save on interest you don’t get charged any tax on that saving, because you’re paying off a debt. In that sense, it’s similar to putting the money into an ISA.

You might have debts to pay off

Unless you’re being charged 0% interest on your debts, or have a very low interest debt like a student loan, there’s no point putting money into any sort of savings account until you’ve paid your debts off.

The money you make in interest on your savings will be more than wiped out by the interest you’re paying on your debts. Pay those off first and then you can start putting your extra cash into savings accounts and other investments.

However, the main reasons you should put money into a cash ISA are:

  • You can make more money on your savings than you would in an ordinary savings account, as you don’t have to pay any tax on the interest.
  • You can take the money out at any time if you suddenly need it and you’ll have pretty much the same amount of money you put in, plus a bit of interest.

Money in stock market investments can go up and down wildly in the short term and it’s possible that they could be down just at the moment you need to access your cash. So – if you find the stock market way too scary but you still want to invest some money, a cash ISA is a pretty decent bet.

How do I invest in a cash ISA?

Easy. You get it in the same way that you would set up any ordinary savings account:

You can now apply for most ISAs online. Alternatively, if you want a postal one or you’d rather open your ISA over the counter,  go to one of the branches of bank or building society concerned and ask to open up the cash ISA you choose.

An online cash ISA may be easier to pay into, withdraw from and manage. On the other hand, by making your money accessible only by walking into the branch in person, you’re reducing your chances of dipping into your savings without thinking.

You know yourself better than anyone so make an informed decision about how much you trust yourself with the money!

Top Fixed Rate ISAs

With these accounts the interest rates are guaranteed not to change throughout the fixed term (though you will be penalised if you take out any money during that term).

Best 1 year fixed rates:

Best 2 year fixed rates:

  • NatWest 2 Year Fixed Rate ISA pays 3.5% with a minimum deposit of £1,000. You can choose between a 1,2 or 3 fixed rate with this ISA, but the interest rates get better the longer the account is opened for; for example if you take out a 1-year fixed ISA the interest is 2.6%, but for 2 years it jumps to 3.5% and pays at 3.7% for a 3-year ISA. Withdrawals are not permitted, and if the account is closed early it is subject to lose of interest.

Best 3 year fixed rate:

  • Northern Rock Fixed Rate e-ISA Issue 18 pays 4.01% for a 3-year fixed rate. This account must be opened online, and the initial investment needed is £500. Withdrawals are subject to loss of interest.

Best 5 year fixed rate:

  • The Halifax Fixed ISA Saver has 3 month-5 year terms available offering 4.40% AER, all on deposits of £500 or more. No additional deposits or withdrawals are allowed. Early closure is permitted but you will lose interest. For the Halifax Fixed Rate ISAs, interest is either paid on maturity, monthly on three and six month terms, monthly or quarterly on nine month terms or quarterly or yearly on a one to five year term.

Top Variable Rate ISAs

Instant access account

  • Halifax ISA saver online offers 2.60% tax free/AER variable including 12 month fixed bonus of 2.35%. Minimum investment £1, transfers into the account are permitted as are withdrawals.

Notice accounts

  • Principality BS is offering a 60-day Direct Account at 2.6% AER with just a £1,000 minimum deposit. The account is managed by post. The rate includes a 1.0% bonus for the first year.

17 Responses to “Saving: cash ISAs – how to choose the best”

  1. Bushra says:

    I can sing.I have got nice sweat voice. Is anybody in advertising is interested to use my voice in Ads .Thanks

  2. rosalie barker says:

    I have had £7.500 in an ISA with Barclays for 3 years and they now tell me the rate is dropping to to just over 2%. I know I can get a better rate but how do I do it. Thanks.

    • Take a look at our article above and pick the best accounts that we suggest if you want to switch to a cash Isa or (better in my opinion) look at this article http://www.moneymagpie.com/article/785/best-equities-isas-shares/ to find out about switching to a shares Isa. Essentially, the company you want to switch to will do the work for you. You choose the cash or shares Isa you want to move your money to, get in touch with the company, tell them which company you’re with at the moment and what your account number is and they will do the rest. The only problem right now is that it often takes longer than it should to transfer the money because the company you’re with might drag its feet. However, there are now moves to force them to transfer quickly so you may find that it happens a bit faster. In fact, let us know how long it takes – we’re monitoring it!

  3. Kath says:

    what is the best cash ISA with out being charged if I want to withdraw cash at anytime?

  4. peter durkin says:

    It would be nice if you updated your page as we in a new tax year!!!!!!!!!!!

  5. Martin says:

    I have a cash Isa for this year with one provider can i take out a stocks and shares ISA with another provider upto my allowance of £7200 and what is a good recommendation for a managed fund

    • Paul Prowse says:

      Hi Martin,
      You can take out a stocks and shares ISA with another provider, up to your allowance of £7,200.

      We don’t tend to recommend managed funds however – they tend to be more expensive and you often get sub-standard returns on your investment. However, you can see how various managed funds are performing through the independent website Moneyspider (http://www.moneyspider.com/).

      Take a look at our article on shares ISAs (http://www.moneymagpie.com/article/785/best-equities-isas-shares/) to get an idea of the options available to you – you may find that investing through something like an Exchange Traded Fund (ETF) may be a better bet.

  6. Maggie Golden says:

    Dear Jasmine, can you clarify this advice I heard on the TV from a well known financial advisor who said around March this year that if you have not already paid your allowance into an ISA for this year (meaning 2008/09) then do it before the 5 April 09 and you will get the whole years interest on it. Is this correct?

  7. Maggie Golden says:

    I heard a well known financial advisor on the TV saying around March this year that if you have not already paid your allowance into an ISA for this year (meaning 2008/09) then do it before the 5 April 09 and you will get the years interest on it. Is this correct?

  8. Richard says:

    Dear Jasmine,

    Can you please clarify something for me?

    I have invested in cash ISA’s for the last few years. In order to get the top rate of interest, I have opened up two new ISA’s in the last two years (one in each year), with HSBC and Alliance & Leicester. The previous ISA was with halifax. I’ve seen new deals with people like Newcastle Building Society (although they have now closed applications for the 5% fixed rate) and I would like to transfer all three ISAs into a new account that pays a better rate than my current providers.

    Unfortunately HSBC didn’t stop the automatic payment from my current account to my ISA at the beginning of this year, and therefore £300 was paid into that ISA by mistake.

    Can I transfer the balances from previous years to a new ISA provider, and not pay in any more to that account this financial year, whilst paying in the remaining entitlement of £3300 into the HSBC ISA?

    • Hello Richard,

      That’s a confusing one!

      However, I have checked around and it looks like you can transfer previous years ISA funds into a new one, as long as you don’t pay anything else into it this tax year – as you have already paid into the HSBC one.

      Hope that helps

  9. Hi Carol – Probably best to check with the savings companies you have moved to. Of course, it’s only June now so it’s quite possible you still have some allowance left since April.

  10. Carol – I doubt if you can open another regular saver with First Direct but why not give them a ring and ask? They’re very helpful

  11. heather says:

    Dear Jasmine

    Thank you so much for very helpful tips and comments.

    It has been necessary to move money around and I do have ISA’s. How can I check if still have an allowance this year as i have lost track using different sources?
    Thank you

  12. Carol Martin says:

    Last year I had aFirst direct Regular Saver , I notice they are advertising this again, will I be able to open another account again, I already have a current account with them

  13. pauline says:

    I have money in a cash free Isa with Nationwide, the interest is pathetic, however I do not fee inclined to move from Nationwide. Can I put this years £3,600 into a new ISA with Nat west? I do have an account with Nat West

    • Yes Pauline you can. The only thing is that if you transfer over your previous balance the amount of cash you’ll be paid interest on is bigger and so you will make more money.

Leave a Reply

Categories