Contrarian Investing: Why Going Against the Grain Can Lead to Big Wins

What is Contrarian Investing?

At its core, contrarian investing is a strategy where you go against the prevailing market sentiment. Instead of buying when everyone else is buying, and selling when everyone else is selling, you do the opposite.

Contrarians often buy when prices are low and the market is pessimistic, and sell when prices are high and the market is overly optimistic.

The idea behind contrarian investing is simple: when most people are panicking and selling off their investments, the prices of stocks and other assets tend to be undervalued. On the other hand, when everyone is overly optimistic and buying into a stock or trend, prices can become inflated and eventually fall back down.

Contrarians believe that following the herd can lead to poor investment decisions, while bucking the trend can lead to opportunities for higher returns.

But it’s not just about doing the opposite for the sake of it—it’s about being data-driven, strategic, and patient. Contrarian investing involves identifying opportunities where the market has overreacted, either to bad news or overly optimistic projections, and making a calculated decision to take advantage of those low prices.

You might like: How to find undervalued stocks

How Contrarian Investing Works

Contrarian investing relies on two main principles: market cycles and human psychology. Understanding these can give you a clearer picture of how this strategy works in practice.

Market Cycles

The stock market doesn’t move in a straight line. It goes through cycles of highs and lows, and these cycles are often driven by emotions such as fear and greed.

During a bull market, everyone gets excited, and prices can soar beyond their intrinsic value. On the other hand, during a bear market or downturn, fear takes over, and prices can drop lower than they should.

Contrarians take advantage of these swings by buying when prices are low (during a bear market) and selling when they’re high (during a bull market).

Human Psychology

Human emotions play a huge role in market movements.

When people are optimistic and excited, they tend to overlook risks, pushing prices higher than they should be.

But when people are fearful and pessimistic, they often sell off assets, causing prices to fall too much.

Contrarian investors recognize these emotional overreactions and use them to their advantage. Instead of being swept up in the excitement or panic, they keep a cool head, evaluate the fundamentals, and look for opportunities where the market is mispricing an asset.

Why is Contrarian Investing Effective?

So, why does contrarian investing work? Well, there are a few key reasons:

Market inefficiencies: The market doesn’t always get it right. Sometimes, investors overreact to bad news, causing a stock’s price to fall too much. Other times, they become too optimistic and inflate a stock’s price beyond its actual value. Contrarians see these inefficiencies as opportunities.
Long-term perspective: Contrarian investing requires patience and a long-term perspective. You have to be willing to ride out short-term volatility and ignore the noise of the market. When you have a solid understanding of a company’s fundamentals and its long-term growth potential, you can hold onto your investments through the ups and downs.
Contrarian investors have less competition: When everyone is jumping on the same bandwagon, the market becomes crowded, and it’s harder to find opportunities for profit. Contrarians, on the other hand, are often swimming against the tide, which can give them an edge in finding undervalued assets before the rest of the market catches on.
Buying low, selling high: The basic principle of investing is to buy low and sell high. Yet, many investors end up doing the opposite because they buy when stocks are high and sell when they are low—driven by fear or greed. Contrarians stick to the principle of buying when others are fearful and selling when others are overly optimistic, allowing them to capitalize on price fluctuations.

Examples of Contrarian Investing Success Stories

There’s a reason that this investing strategy is so popular! Contrarian investing has led to some big wins for investors who were willing to go against the crowd. Here are a few examples:

Warren Buffett and Coca-Cola

Warren Buffett, the most famous contrarian investor of them all, has made his fortune by identifying opportunities when others were fearful. One of his most famous contrarian moves was investing in Coca-Cola in 1988.

At the time, Coca-Cola’s stock was struggling due to declining sales, and many investors were avoiding it. However, Buffett saw the brand’s potential and the long-term strength of its market position. He bought a large stake in Coca-Cola when the market was undervaluing it.

Today, that investment is worth billions.

John Templeton and the 1930s

John Templeton is another legendary contrarian investor. In the 1930s, Templeton made a bold move by buying stocks during the Great Depression. While many investors were running for the hills, Templeton saw an opportunity in the beaten-down stock market.

He invested in 100 companies that were trading for under $1 per share, and by the time the market recovered, those investments paid off handsomely.

His approach to buying during times of fear and uncertainty helped him amass a fortune.

Buying the Housing Market During the 2008 Crash

During the 2008 financial crisis, real estate and housing markets were in freefall, and investors were running scared.

However, some contrarian investors saw this as an opportunity to buy real estate at rock-bottom prices.

By doing so, they were able to capitalize on the eventual recovery of the housing market, which led to significant profits.

How to Implement a Contrarian Investing Strategy

Contrarian investing isn’t for the faint-hearted. It requires a strong belief in your research, the ability to tune out market noise, and a willingness to go against the grain (plus, you need to be pretty risk-tolerant!).

Here’s how you can implement a contrarian strategy in your own investing journey:

Look for undervalued stocks: Look for companies with solid fundamentals—like strong earnings, low debt, and a competitive advantage—that are being sold off for reasons unrelated to their intrinsic value. These stocks are often priced lower than they should be, giving you an opportunity to buy at a discount.
Research the fundamentals: While many investors are driven by headlines and market sentiment, contrarians focus on the fundamentals. Look at a company’s financials, business model, and industry position. If the company is solid but the stock price has dropped due to temporary market conditions, that’s a contrarian opportunity.
Tune out the noise: Contrarian investors know that the market is often driven by emotions, not logic. To succeed in this strategy, you need to be able to tune out the short-term noise and focus on the long-term picture. Don’t let the market’s fear or excitement sway your decisions.
Have patience Contrarian investing requires a long-term mindset. You may need to wait for months or even years for the market to catch up to your thesis. If you’re not prepared to hold through volatility, this strategy may not be for you.
Buy when everyone is selling, sell when everyone is buying The core principle of contrarian investing is buying when the market is fearful and selling when the market is overly optimistic. Be prepared to make moves that others might consider risky, but do so with confidence in your research and strategy.

Risks of Contrarian Investing

Of course, contrarian investing isn’t without its risks. Going against the crowd means you might be wrong, and it could take longer for the market to realize the value you see.

Timing the market is incredibly difficult, even for seasoned investors. While contrarians often buy during market dips, there’s no guarantee that the market will rebound quickly—or that the asset will ever return to its previous highs.

It’s also important to remember that contrarian investing requires patience, and this can be challenging. If the market doesn’t immediately react to the mispricing you’ve identified, you may be left holding onto a losing investment for longer than you expected.

It’s important to remember that just because the majority of investors are buying or selling something doesn’t mean they’re wrong. Sometimes, the market gets it right, and being a contrarian doesn’t always lead to profits.

Final Thoughts

Contrarian investing isn’t for everyone, but for those who are willing to think independently, do their research, and be patient, it can be a powerful strategy.

Going against the grain can lead to big wins when you spot opportunities that others overlook, and it can allow you to capitalize on market inefficiencies. However, it’s not without its risks, and you must be prepared for short-term volatility and uncertainty.

If you’re considering adopting a contrarian strategy, make sure you have a strong understanding of the companies or assets you’re investing in, and be prepared to tune out the noise. In the world of investing, sometimes it pays to swim against the current (but not always!).

Are you interested in learning more about investing? Why not sign up to the MoneyMagpie bi-weekly Investing Newsletter? It’s free and you can unsubscribe at any time if you find it isn’t for you.

Disclaimer: MoneyMagpie is not a licensed financial advisor and therefore information found here including opinions, commentary, suggestions or strategies are for informational, entertainment or educational purposes only. This should not be considered as financial advice. Anyone thinking of investing should conduct their own due diligence. When investing your capital is at risk.

Contrarian Investing: Why Going Against the Grain Can Lead to Big Wins

What is Contrarian Investing?