Jasmine Birtles
Your money-making expert. Financial journalist, TV and radio personality.
Millions Never Check This! MoneyMagpie Warn You to Not Miss Out On This Council Tax Saving
Vicky Parry
14th Oct 2025
Could You Be Overpaying Without Realising?
Let me start with something that might surprise you: your council tax band is probably based on how much your property was worth over 30 years ago.
In England, bands are based on 1991 valuations: regardless of how much your home is worth now, or what’s changed since then. In Wales, the cutoff is 2003; still over 20 years ago. That means your band might never have been updated to reflect extensions, area changes, conversions, or even just errors made at the time.
Worse still? Most of these bands were estimated in a hurry, using street-level assumptions and sometimes limited data. Properties were grouped together, and many homes were never rechecked; meaning thousands of households may have been overpaying for decades.
The good news: thousands of people challenge their band each year and many get money back. You could be one of them.
In this guide, I’ll show you:
- How council tax bands are decided across the UK
- How many people are in the wrong band (official figures)
- What you could save and how to get a refund
- How to check, challenge, and change your band: step by step
- What you need to watch out for so it doesn’t backfire
If you haven’t checked your band before, this is your sign. It could save you hundreds and it’s easier than you think.
What Are the Bands Based On?
- In England, council tax bands are based on property values as of 1 April 1991. (GOV.UK)
- In Wales, the valuation date is 1 April 2003. (GOV.UK)
- These historic baselines mean that any changes to your property since then (extensions, conversions, deterioration) aren’t automatically reflected.
- Because valuations were sometimes approximate and based on limited data or external observation, errors and anomalies are common.
How Many Are Challenging — And How Many Succeed?
- In the year to 31 March 2024, the VOA received 43,820 challenges to council tax bands in England & Wales. (GOV.UK)
- Of those, 39,590 were resolved. (GOV.UK)
- In the outcomes:
That means over one in four successful challenges sees a reduction. It’s not guaranteed, but it’s far from trivial.
What You Could Save (and Reclaim)
- If your band is lowered, your future council tax bills will drop. The amount depends on how much your council charges per band in your area.
- You’ll also be able to claim back overpayments (refunds) — the amount backdated depends on your time in the property, local rules, and how far off the band was. HOA (Homeowners Alliance) states that refunds can be “£100s” or even “£1,000s” in some cases. (HomeOwners Alliance)
- Even a one-band drop might save hundreds annually, especially in higher‑rate areas.
Step-by-Step: Check, Challenge & Change Your Band
1. Check your band and comparators
- Use GOV.UK’s “Challenge your Council Tax band” service (enter postcode + address) to see your band and neighbouring ones. (GOV.UK)
- Compare your property with similar houses in your street or area (same type, size, age).
- Differences in band among such comparables may suggest your band is incorrect.
2. Gather evidence (your case materials)
When you make a challenge, you’ll need compelling evidence. Official guidelines warn:
- You can submit up to 5 comparable properties in lower bands (must be similar in type, size, age, design). (GOV.UK)
- Sales evidence must be from relevant windows: for England, between 1 April 1989 and 31 March 1993 is valid. (GOV.UK)
- The VOA will not accept average house price indices from sites like Zoopla, Nationwide, or Rightmove as standalone evidence. (GOV.UK)
- Fill out the property details questionnaire and, if you are submitting on behalf of someone else, include an Authority to Act form (signed within 6 months). (GOV.UK)
3. Decide which route: Proposal vs Review
- A Proposal is your legal right to challenge in certain circumstances (e.g. you have paid tax for less than 6 months; your band was changed in last 6 months; or there’s been a physical change to the property). (GOV.UK)
- A Band Review is less formal — you can request this even if you don’t have the right to propose. The VOA may review it if evidence is strong. (GOV.UK)
4. Submit your challenge
- Use the GOV.UK online challenge form for England & Wales. (GOV.UK)
- Or send the Council Tax challenge form + your evidence to [email protected]. (GOV.UK)
- If you are acting on behalf of someone else, include the Authority to Act. (GOV.UK)
Note: You must continue paying your current council tax while the challenge is processed. (GOV.UK)
5. Wait for the outcome — and appeal if needed
- VOA usually confirms receipt within up to 28 days. (GOV.UK)
- If you made a Proposal, the VOA has up to 6 months to decide. (GOV.UK)
- If it’s a Band Review, it may take up to 12 months. (GOV.UK)
- If you disagree and you had a legal right to propose, you may appeal to the Valuation Tribunal in England (or Wales). Appeals usually must be made within 3 months. (GOV.UK)
- If the tribunal rules in your favour, VOA changes your band, council reissues your bill, and refunds any overpayments. (GOV.UK)
Risks, Caveats & Common Pitfalls
- Some challenges may lead to band increases, though in practice this is rare. (GOV.UK)
- Weak evidence (poor comparables, vague data) often leads to “no change” outcomes.
- Missing appeal deadlines can forfeit your legal route.
- You cannot stop paying the current band while waiting for decision.
- Changes to your property after the valuation date may be legitimate reasons for higher banding.
What You Can Do Today (Quick Checklist)
- Look up your current council tax band on GOV.UK.
- Check neighbours / similar houses to see if any are in lower bands.
- Gather addresses, sale data, floorplans, property documents.
- Fill in the challenge form + evidence + questionnaire / Authority to Act (if needed).
- Submit via VOA.
- Track your case and prepare to appeal (if applicable).
Why This Matters — And Why You Should Share It
- Overpaying council tax is a hidden cost many endure for years.
- A dropped band or successful challenge can yield hundreds per year plus refunds.
- It’s a do‑it‑yourself right that many don’t know exists — sharing helps others avoid overpaying too.
Subscribe
Login
0 Comments
